
Bella was kidnapped at five and brought home at sixteen, when George, a detective, matched her records. By then her parents, Paul and Evelyn, had adopted Anna, a piano player close to Bella's age.
Anna soon has her parents' trust. She says Bella hid a blade in a bracelet to cut her hand, and later she says Bella stole $3,000 from the house. Paul and Evelyn believe Anna each time, and Bella is treated like a stranger in her own home.
One Christmas Bella stops coming home. Anna says she rode off on a motorcycle with some punk, and Bella's phone is switched off.
Bella, who was kidnapped at five and brought home at sixteen, opens the series speaking after her own death. Her adoptive sister Anna, who plays piano, has taken much of the family's attention since she arrived. Paul, a detective, and Evelyn, a coroner, side with Anna when she claims Bella hid a blade in a bracelet to cut her hand. On Christmas Bella goes out, and Anna says she rode off on a motorcycle with a punk. Days later a dismembered body is found on the beach at a tourist site.
George, a detective on Paul's team, leads the search for the rest of the body, and Evelyn examines the remains. More pieces turn up in a restaurant sewer, and Evelyn confirms they come from the same girl. Anna turns up at the scene knowing details of the case she could only have heard at home, and then she says Bella stole $3,000 and bought a new phone. Bella stops answering calls for three days, and Evelyn decides she has run off.
The series goes back to Bella's homecoming, when George matched her records and brought her to a house where Anna already lived. In the present, Evelyn's mother begs George to find Bella, but Evelyn and Paul call her a runaway. Anna tells them Bella bullied her at school, and Bella says Anna locked her in a restroom, but the parents believe Anna. On Christmas Eve a gift arrives at the door, and the family argues over whether to open it.
An anonymous tip sends the detectives to a house where the victim's head is found in a pot. A prayer card found at St. John's Cathedral asks God to protect Paul and Evelyn, and a priest says a quiet young girl prayed there for her parents. The same prayer turns up inside the victim's mouth, and Anna, in a row over her competition, says Bella is dead.
A facial reconstruction of the victim comes back, and Paul insists it is not Bella. The DNA result says otherwise, and Paul recognizes the scar on the leg. Footage from Santa Monica shows Bella on the street, and then Anna arrives there late at night. Anna offers to bring Bella to a man and promises him $100,000 if he kills her.
Anna is brought home and says she won first place in her piano competition. Paul questions her about the night Bella died, and Anna says she saw Bella with a man in Santa Monica and called her to come home. Her DNA is not found at the crime scene and she has an alibi, so she is let go. Her parents still take her side.
Anna's phone records show a contact, an ex-convict released three years earlier, named Jack. Jack is the son of a man Paul arrested, and that man was given the death penalty. He tells Paul and Evelyn that he cut out Bella's tongue after she defended them, and that he put her out of her misery. The confrontation ends with a collapse and a call for an ambulance.
Anna wins the state piano competition and thanks her parents in a speech, and Paul is there in the audience. She is arrested after the kidnapper confesses that Anna offered him $100,000 to kill Bella. When her parents confront her, Anna says they believed her every time she blamed Bella. In the last two episodes Paul and Evelyn beg Bella to forgive them.
Bella
The real daughter, kidnapped at five and brought home at sixteen. She is killed in the series and narrates it from after her death.
Anna
The adopted sister, a piano player whom the parents took in while Bella was missing. She turns the family against Bella.
Paul
Bella's father and a homicide detective, who ends up working the case of his own daughter.
Evelyn
Bella's mother and the coroner who examines the remains.
Jack
A former prisoner whose father Paul arrested. He is the man who kills Bella.
George
A detective on Paul's team and a family friend. He matched Bella's records when she came home at sixteen.
In the last episode, the gifts Bella bought for her parents are shown: a massager for her father's shoulder and a candle to help her mother sleep, each card signed 'Love, Bella.' The parents break down over them, and the last line says Bella is not gone, only taking a nap. It means they still speak of her as if she is alive, even after what happened to her.
Yes. The kidnapper confessed that Anna offered him $100,000 to kill Bella, and Anna is arrested in episode 47.
Jack did. In episodes 43 and 44 he tells Paul and Evelyn that he cut out her tongue and then put her out of her misery.
Because it is only about 90% accurate, and Paul insisted the woman in it could be a lookalike. The DNA results in episode 32 settled that the body is Bella.
Bella did. In episode 28 she says the card is hers, and it is a prayer asking God to protect her parents.