
Emma Carter is a quiet student who has been Olivia's best friend since middle school. Olivia has been dating Anton Walker, the star quarterback of their college, for almost a year.
One night Emma is sleeping in Olivia's room when a man comes in from the dark and kisses her, thinking she is Olivia. It is Anton, who was supposed to be away in Boston all week. When he sees who she is, he apologizes, and the two agree to say nothing to Olivia.
Emma wants to keep her distance from Anton, who seems too intense to her, but they keep running into each other. At the dinner the three of them share, he says almost nothing. Lucas Bennett, a senior and vice president of the Student Union, starts leaving a bagel and a vanilla latte on Emma's desk, with a sticky note that says Don't skip breakfast.
Emma Carter, a shy student who has been Olivia's best friend since middle school, is sleeping in Olivia's room when a man comes in during the night and kisses her, thinking she is Olivia. He is Anton Walker, Olivia's boyfriend and the star quarterback, and they agree to keep the night from Olivia. At the dinner the next evening Anton says almost nothing, and when he walks Emma home the night guard at her building assumes they are a couple. Lucas Bennett, a senior and vice president of the Student Union, starts leaving breakfast and sticky notes on Emma's desk.
At a Student Union party, Lucas sings a love song while looking at Emma, then Emma sees Olivia and Lucas slip out the back door into an alley. Hiding behind a door, Emma overhears them mock her and admit they have been sleeping together. As she moves to confront them, Anton grabs her wrist and pulls her into an empty room, where he asks what she thinks of his kissing. Later at the same party Anton is drunk and shaken, and when he leans on her, she pushes him away and goes home.
Olivia comes to Emma's apartment crying and says she and Anton have broken up, though she won't say why. Emma remembers how Olivia gave her new clothes in middle school, and she chooses to forgive Olivia. Lucas keeps pushing, and after a Student Union meeting he grabs Emma's wrist, yanks her backpack, and she falls hard onto the floor. Anton punches Lucas away, and on the drive home he stares at the pink butterfly birthmark beside Emma's collarbone.
Olivia, still trying to win Anton back, asks Emma to co-lead a charity gala, and they meet its main sponsor, Richard Coleman, a vice president at a large corporation. At a dinner to lock in the sponsorship, Olivia hands Emma a drink, and Emma wakes later in a hotel room, unable to move. Emma overhears Olivia and Richard talk, Olivia calls Emma a toy and asks that the gala partnership stay under her own name. When Richard comes back to the bed, Emma hits him on the head with a glass she has hidden under the sheet, then runs out into the hall.
Yes. Anton ends things with Olivia, and after the kiss in episode 24 he walks up to Emma in the final scene and they leave for a movie.
Because Olivia saw Emma in Anton's jacket getting into his car, and she wanted Emma out of the way so she could win Anton back. She gives Emma a drink at the sponsor dinner in episode 14 and then talks with Richard about it in the hotel room.
Emma did. Olivia claimed the rescue while dating Anton, but in episode 23 Anton's school pin and the pink butterfly birthmark he remembered point to Emma.
A small pink butterfly birthmark. He stares at it in episode 12, and it matches the mark he remembered from the drowning rescue.
Emma runs into Anton on a floor above the gala hall, and he carries her to his car to take her to the emergency room. Emma pulls him into the back seat instead, and they spend the night together. The next morning Emma wakes in Anton's guest room, and Olivia arrives at the door with breakfast. Wearing one of Anton's white shirts, Emma tells Olivia she heard everything Olivia said to Richard.
Anton tells Olivia it is over, then walks past her into the house. Emma admits she used Anton for revenge in the car, and he says whatever her reason was, he wanted it too. He brings out a metal box with a school pin from a high school freshman camp, and reminds Emma she once saved a boy from drowning there. Anton says Olivia had claimed that rescue as her own, and that the girl he remembered had a pink butterfly birthmark. Emma remembers Olivia telling her about a hot-water burn scar at swim practice, and when Anton says it was Emma all along, they share their first real kiss.
Olivia blames Emma for losing the sponsor and shows photos of Emma passed out with Richard's arm around her. The school expels Olivia, and as she leaves she admits she seduced Lucas only because he liked Emma, and says she does not regret taking Anton. Anton walks up, ignores Olivia, and asks Emma if she is ready for their movie.
Emma Carter
The main character, a quiet student who has been Olivia's best friend since middle school and who is drugged at a sponsor dinner.
Olivia
Emma's best friend and Anton's girlfriend, who sets Emma up to win Anton back and claims a rescue that was Emma's.
Anton Walker
The college's star quarterback and Olivia's boyfriend, who later becomes Emma's partner once he learns she is the girl who saved him from drowning.
Lucas Bennett
The Student Union vice president who pursues Emma with breakfasts and is secretly involved with Olivia.
Richard Coleman
The main sponsor of the charity gala, a vice president at a large corporation, whose hotel room is where Emma wakes after the drink.
Anton is at Emma's side in the final scene, and Olivia, who spent years as Emma's closest friend, is shut out of it. The friendship that began in middle school ended in lies, and the man Emma first thought was cold is the one she chooses to be with.